Feedback Is a Gift — If You Know How to Unwrap It
The Moment You Stop Listening
Someone gives you feedback after a lecture, a case review, a committee meeting. Before they finish their second sentence, your brain is already drafting a response. Not a response to what they said. A rebuttal.
You are not unusual. You are a physician.
Why This Happens
Your training taught you that being wrong has consequences. Real ones. So your nervous system learned to treat any suggestion that you fell short as a threat to be neutralized. Fast.
The problem is that this reflex does not distinguish between a life-threatening mistake in the ICU and a colleague telling you that your presentation could have been more concise. It fires the same way every time.
Sheila Heen and Douglas Stone describe this in Thanks for the Feedback as an "identity trigger." When your self-concept is built on competence -- and whose isn't, after a decade of medical training -- feedback can feel less like information and more like an attack on who you are.
Defensive Posture vs. Learning Posture
There are really only two ways to receive feedback. You can protect yourself, or you can learn something.
The defensive posture sounds like:
- "They don't understand the full picture."
- "That's not fair given the circumstances."
- "I already know that."
The learning posture sounds like:
- "What part of this might be true?"
- "What would I do differently if I took this seriously?"
- "What is this person seeing that I can't?"
You do not have to accept every piece of feedback as gospel. Most of it is imperfect. But if you never get past the defensive posture, you never find out which parts were worth hearing.
One Move That Changes Everything
Here is the simplest shift I teach in coaching. When feedback lands and your chest tightens, say this: "Thank you. Let me think about that."
That is it. You do not agree. You do not argue. You buy yourself enough time for your prefrontal cortex to catch up to your amygdala.
I have watched this one sentence change how physician leaders relate to their chairs, their peers, and their trainees. It turns a moment of friction into a moment of credibility. People trust leaders who can hear hard things without flinching.
The Superpower Nobody Talks About
In academic medicine, the physicians who advance are not always the smartest in the room. They are often the ones who can take input without breaking. The ones peers actually want to give honest feedback to, because they know it will be received.
That is a superpower. And it is entirely learnable.
You do not need to love feedback. You just need to stop losing valuable information to a reflex you never chose.
Explore our individual coaching options to see how coaching can support your growth.
