Physician Mental Health: How Far We've Come and How Far We Have to Go
The Question Nobody Used to Ask
Five years ago, if you asked a room full of physicians how they were really doing, you would get polished non-answers. Fine. Busy. You know how it is. The physician mental health stigma was so thick that admitting struggle felt like admitting incompetence.
That is changing. Slowly, imperfectly, but measurably. And it matters that we acknowledge the progress without pretending the job is done.
What Has Actually Gotten Better
Give credit where it is due. The conversation around physician wellness progress has shifted in real ways.
The Dr. Lorna Breen Heroes' Foundation, created after Dr. Breen's death during the COVID-19 pandemic, pushed physician mental health into the public conversation in a way that previous efforts had not. The Dr. Lorna Breen Health Care Provider Protection Act, signed into law in 2022, directed federal funding toward mental health programs for health care workers.
More tangibly, state medical boards have started changing their licensing applications. A 2023 report from the Dr. Lorna Breen Heroes' Foundation found that the majority of U.S. states have now removed or modified intrusive mental health questions from licensing applications. That is a big deal. For decades, physicians avoided therapy because they feared a licensing board would use it against them. That fear was not irrational. It was based on how the questions were written.
Residency programs have expanded access to confidential counseling. Major academic medical centers have hired chief wellness officers. The language has shifted toward a broader, more honest framing of mental health in academic medicine.
What Has Not Changed Enough
Here is where I have to be direct. Progress on paper does not always translate to progress in hallways, operating rooms, and faculty meetings.
- The culture of toughness persists. Medicine still selects for and rewards people who push through. The informal message in many departments is still that needing help is a weakness. No policy memo overrides what a department chair signals with a raised eyebrow.
- Licensing questions still exist in some states. Not all boards have reformed their applications. Even where the questions have changed, many physicians do not know it. The old fear lingers.
- Structural drivers remain untouched. You can offer every counseling benefit in the world, but if the workload, administrative burden, and lack of autonomy stay the same, you are treating symptoms. As Tait Shanafelt and colleagues have argued repeatedly in Mayo Clinic Proceedings, individual wellness programs without system-level change are insufficient.
- Access is uneven. A physician at a well-resourced academic medical center may have a wellness program, confidential counseling, and peer support. A physician at a smaller community hospital or in private practice may have none of that.
Think of it like a sports team that finally acknowledged its players were getting injured too often. Buying better ice packs was a start. But if the practice schedule and coaching methods do not change, the injuries keep coming.
What Institutions Can Do Right Now
The next phase of physician wellness progress requires institutions to move beyond awareness campaigns and into operational change.
- Audit your licensing and credentialing questions. If your institution's own credentialing forms still ask intrusive mental health questions, fix them. You do not need to wait for a state board.
- Make access genuinely confidential. Physicians need to trust that using mental health resources will not appear in their file or affect their privileges. That trust has to be earned through policy and practice.
- Address workload. Christine Sinsky's research at the AMA has shown that for every hour of direct patient care, physicians spend nearly two hours on EHR and administrative tasks. That ratio is a mental health issue. Institutions serious about wellbeing have to be serious about reducing unnecessary work.
- Normalize the conversation from the top. When department chairs and deans talk openly about mental health, it gives permission to everyone else. Leadership modeling matters more than any wellness newsletter.
What Individuals Can Do
You do not have to wait for your institution to get this right. Seeking support is not a sign that you are failing. It is a sign that you are functioning in a system that was not designed with your wellbeing in mind and you are doing something about it. A coach, a therapist, a peer support group. The specific resource matters less than the act of reaching out.
The physician mental health stigma is weaker than it used to be. But it is still there. Every physician who gets help and talks about it honestly chips away at it a little more. We have come a long way. We are not there yet. The direction is right, and the pace can accelerate if institutions and individuals both keep pushing.
Check out our individual coaching options.
